The challenge
A Toyota dealership in one of the largest U.S. dealer groups was running service marketing across email, direct mail, paid search, and paid social. The question wasn’t whether customers were responding. It was which channels were actually bringing cars into the service lane, and what each one was worth.
What DataClover did
- Ran service email and direct mail, alongside paid search and paid social
- Matched every response to a closed repair order in the dealership’s DMS
- Counted each repair order once, even when a customer touched more than one channel
- Reported results by rooftop and for the group in ServicePulse Analytics
The results
Over one quarter (July through September 2026), the program produced 264 repair orders and $128,564 in service revenue: a 4.9× return on spend.
| Channel | Repair orders | Revenue | Average RO |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paid search (calls and online) | 138 | $82,473 | $598 |
| 100 | $38,239 | $382 | |
| Direct mail | 14 | $2,951 | $211 |
| Paid social | 8 | $3,620 | $452 |
| Organic and direct | 4 | $1,282 | $321 |
| All channels | 264 | $128,564 | $487 |
- Email produced 100 repair orders, a 24.1× return on spend.
- Paid search brought the highest-value visits, averaging $598 per repair order.
- Direct mail produced 14 repair orders in its first two months, growing month over month.
Winning customers back
Retention isn’t only about customers who were just in. 18 customers who had been away for 13 to 24 months came back through email and direct mail, worth $7,773 in service revenue. Email brought back 14 of them.
Why it worked
Every channel was measured the same way: against closed repair orders, counted once. That told the dealership not just that its marketing was working, but which channel brought which customers, from regulars to owners it had nearly lost.